COSLAB Insight · U.S. Beauty

Washington's Preservative Ban: The List of 25 Is Not the Limit

Under a rule Washington State adopted on 28 August 2025, cosmetics containing any of 25 intentionally added formaldehyde-releasing ingredients cannot be manufactured, sold or distributed in the state from 1 January 2027. The important part is not the list but the definition. In clarifying what intentionally added means, the rule also restricts formaldehyde releasers that are not on the list. For a brand shipping into the United States, the work is therefore not deleting 25 names from an ingredient list but being able to explain why the preservative system is built the way it is.

Share this insight

What is the signal?

The Washington State Department of Ecology adopted its cosmetics rule on 28 August 2025. It restricts a list of 25 formaldehyde-releasing chemicals and, at the same time, clarifies the definition of intentionally added so that other formaldehyde-releasing chemicals are restricted too. Ecology's compliance guidance states that no person may manufacture, knowingly sell, offer for sale, or distribute a cosmetic product that contains one or more of the 25 intentionally added formaldehyde releasers. The restriction on the releasers takes effect on 1 January 2027. Names confirmed on the list include DMDM hydantoin, diazolidinyl urea, imidazolidinyl urea, quaternium-15, sodium hydroxymethylglycinate, methenamine, paraformaldehyde and tosylamide/formaldehyde resin.

This rule is the next step of a law that is already running. Washington's Toxic-Free Cosmetics Act (Chapter 70A.560 RCW) took effect on 1 January 2025 and restricts five chemicals and four chemical classes when intentionally added. Formaldehyde itself, and methylene glycol as its hydrated form, were restricted at that point. The retail stage has already closed as well: since 1 January 2026 in-state retailers may not sell or donate products that do not comply with those restrictions. So 1 January 2027 is not the start of a new regime but the opening of the second column of the same law.

What separates the 2027 column from the earlier one is how a product gets caught. Ecology's concise explanatory statement says the formaldehyde releasers are not limited to the chemicals identified, and the rule reaches any releaser intentionally added for an antimicrobial, preservative, denaturant or cross-linking function. Worth noting: the proposed list carried 28 entries and the adopted list carries 25. The list got shorter while the reach did not get narrower, which tells you the character of the rule. It screens by function, not by name.

The reason to look at this now is the gap between the dates. Manufacture and distribution are caught on 1 January 2027, and only stock an in-state retailer already held before that date may be sold through to 31 December 2027. Changing a preservative system brings reformulation, retesting and updated product records with it, so it is safer to decide this year which standard the next production lot will be built to.

Four limits apply to these dates and figures. First, this is a Washington State law, and the California provisions below belong to another state; it is not a federal ban across the United States. Second, the full set of 25 names with CAS numbers has to be read in the text of WAC 173-339 and on Ecology's compliance page, and the names listed across the Ecology guidance pages we checked do not match exactly, so the rule text is what decides. Third, the lead policy described below is non-enforcement while the policy remains in effect, not a standard. Fourth, follow-up bills have been filed in California that would change the same section again, and whether they are enacted is not established by the material we checked. What follows is our reading of the rule text as it currently stands, and whether any individual product is caught needs to be confirmed against each state's regulation and with a specialist.

1. Products are caught by why an ingredient is there, not by a list of 25

Treat regulatory work as ingredient substitution and this rule catches you a second time. Removing the 25 is necessary but not sufficient, because in defining intentionally added the rule also restricts other formaldehyde releasers added for an antimicrobial, preservative, denaturant or cross-linking function. Switching to a name that is not on the list does not by itself guarantee compliance; why the ingredient is in the formula is assessed alongside it.

The unit of work is therefore not one line of an ingredient list but the whole preservative system. Which ingredient carries the preservative role, what plays a supporting role, and how far the chelating agent and the pH window hold that efficacy up all need to sit on one page before a substitution is possible. Change ingredients without that page and there is no way to see where efficacy falls short; you end up working backwards from a test report.

The documents you need from suppliers change too. Not a single line saying this raw material is not a formaldehyde releaser, but a document giving the ingredient name, the CAS number and the function that material performs in the product. In blends, the name that appears on an ingredient list can differ from what is actually inside, so verification has to happen at constituent level rather than blend level.

On an OEM or ODM project it is better to write down where this responsibility sits at the contract stage: who collects supplier documentation, who checks it against each state's list, and who keeps the result on file. When that question first comes up just before production, the schedule slips in the most expensive way possible.

  • Whether the preservative role and its supporting ingredients sit on one page
  • Whether supplier data arrives at constituent and CAS level, not blend level
  • Whether replacement ingredients were reviewed on function, not only against the list
  • Whether list checking and record keeping were assigned at the contract stage

2. The two dates belong to two different parties

The rule holds two dates that apply to different parties. 1 January 2027 attaches to manufacture, sale, offering for sale and distribution. 31 December 2027 attaches to stock held by in-state retailers and cosmetologists, and only to products they already had on hand before 1 January 2027. The extra year of sell-through does not move the supply-side schedule back by a year.

For an exporting brand this distinction turns into a question about shipping and purchase-order timing. Volume newly placed with a US distributor or retailer in 2027 has to meet the new standard, while product built on the current preservative system needs to be in the counterparty's warehouse beforehand to fall under the sell-through allowance. It is also something a buyer may raise at the order stage as compliance of shipments from 2027 onward.

Channels may put the question differently. A national retail account usually finds it easier to require the strictest specification than to split inventory by state. A restriction that formally binds one state can come back as an order condition that behaves like a national one. Whether to split specifications by state or run a single specification built to the strictest state is a decision that has to be weighed against SKU count and inventory cost.

It is also worth confirming what falls outside scope. Ecology states that the law does not apply to chemicals in product packaging or to FDA-regulated drug ingredients. Outside scope does not mean there is nothing to check, and which classification a given product falls into has to be confirmed product by product.

  • Whether shipments from 2027 and earlier shipments are separated by specification
  • Whether the US warehouse arrival date for current-specification stock was worked backwards
  • Whether split-by-state and single strictest specification were costed against each other
  • Whether the packaging and drug-ingredient exclusions apply to your own items

3. Changing a preservative does not change only the formula

Swapping a preservative system looks like changing one line of an ingredient list, but in practice it rebuilds the safety evidence for the product. Preservative efficacy has to be demonstrated again, and where solubility and pH sensitivity shift, stability testing comes back as well. In our judgement, choosing ingredients before fixing the scope of that retesting is what breaks schedules most often.

Several things move in sequence. A preservative change can affect the pH window, viscosity, how the fragrance develops and colour stability. Container compatibility has to be revisited, because the same bulk can behave differently in terms of sorption into and permeation through the packaging material once the preservative changes. If the sensory profile shifts, existing consumer evaluation data may no longer apply to the product being sold.

Printed matter moves with it. A change of ingredient list means a change of label artwork, and the product records held by channels and distributors need updating. Artwork is usually ordered in minimum quantities, so a changeover that is not aligned with remaining stock creates write-offs. For a brand with many items, deciding the order in which items get changed is effectively a budget decision.

So rather than changing everything at once, we would group the work. Items sharing a preservative system can be retested and documented together, and handling the items with the largest US share first clears the ones under the tightest date pressure. Since minimum production quantities and component stock differ by item, it is better to group by production unit than by formula.

For a new product the situation is simpler. Decide at the planning stage, in one line, whether Washington and California are among the target markets, and the usable preservative range is narrowed before the formula is frozen. Narrowing the range first is almost always cheaper than reopening a formula that has already been fixed.

  • Whether the scope of retesting was fixed before replacement ingredients were chosen
  • Whether container compatibility, pH, viscosity and fragrance shift are on the review list
  • Whether the changeover date is aligned with remaining label artwork stock
  • Whether items sharing a preservative system were grouped and sequenced

4. California adds to its own banned list on the same day

California adds banned ingredients from 1 January 2027 under AB 496. The additions confirmed in the bill text include styrene, trichloroacetic acid, tricresyl phosphate, vinyl acetate, 2-chloracetamide and allyl isothiocyanate, along with boric acid and borate salt forms such as disodium octaborate and borax decahydrate, each with a CAS number. The provisions sit in section 108980 of the California Health and Safety Code.

One thing makes it different in character from the Washington rule. AB 496 carves out a technically unavoidable trace quantity arising from impurities, manufacturing, storage or migration from packaging. Items caught regardless of intentional addition and items excused at trace level fall due on the same date, so which logic applies has to be recorded ingredient by ingredient. Put the two states in one table labelled banned ingredients and that difference disappears.

How much it bites differs by item. The names added in California are met more often in nail and hair formulations. Borate salts are used in some items for buffering or thickening purposes, which makes them worth a pass through the ingredient list even on skincare. Which items are actually affected has to be judged from the real formula and cannot be generalised by category.

If your US items span several states, it is more practical to manage state lists as a single comparison table: columns for the state, the effective date and the applicable logic (intentional addition, or a trace exception), rows for your own ingredients. With that table in place, a new state adding a list means an update rather than starting the research again.

  • Whether Washington and California sit in one table with dates and applicable logic
  • Whether intentional addition and trace exceptions are distinguished per ingredient
  • Whether nail and hair items were given a separate ingredient-list pass
  • Whether the table is built so a new state is an update, not a new project

5. Some items are not caught by reading the ingredient list

Parts of the Washington law already in force cannot be seen on an ingredient list at all. Lead and lead compounds are restricted when present at or above 1 part per million, whether intentionally added or not. Ecology has issued an interim policy under which it will not enforce the 1 ppm limit for products that meet all the requirements of the policy. Option 1 is a lead concentration at or below 2 ppm for general cosmetics, or at or below 5 ppm for colour cosmetics and clay masks. Option 2 covers colour cosmetics and clay masks above 5 ppm and below 10 ppm, with batch monitoring and data retention. This is non-enforcement while the policy stands, so read it as the current state of play rather than as a standard.

There is a trap on the testing side. Ecology's guidance notes that the law's limit for lead in the finished product is ten times lower than the federal limit, so you need to ensure the laboratory's test method has adequate detection and reporting limits. Order the same test item and, if the reporting limit sits above the standard, a result of not detected is not evidence of compliance. When a certificate arrives, read the reporting limit alongside the number.

PFAS is approached differently. Ecology's guidance suggests that screening by testing for total fluorine may be more cost-effective, and recommends reviewing ingredient lists for fluoro- and phthalate. An ingredient-list search costs nothing, so it belongs before any testing.

The box most often left empty is fragrance. Ecology's guidance notes that a fragrance's full formulation may not be disclosed because it is considered a trade secret, and that the fragrance may contain an ortho-phthalate or another restricted chemical. A line that reads only fragrance on an ingredient list is, for regulatory purposes, a blank. A written restricted-substance confirmation from the fragrance house is needed, and it has to be obtained again whenever the fragrance changes.

Confirm these after the product is built and there is almost no room left to act. Supplier documentation and fragrance confirmations are cheaper to collect before the formula is frozen, and a laboratory is safer to appoint after asking which items it can report, and at what reporting limit.

  • Whether the reporting limit on the lead certificate sits below the standard
  • Whether the ingredient list was searched for fluoro- and phthalate first
  • Whether a written restricted-substance confirmation was obtained for the fragrance
  • Whether that confirmation is re-obtained whenever the fragrance changes

The first question for the brief

Replace the line that reads enter the US market with three lines. The first is the states. Write down which states this product will enter, and decide whether to run the strictest of them as a single specification or split by state. If a national channel is in the plan, this line effectively converges on one specification.

The second line is the preservative system. Write down which ingredients carry the preservative role in the current formula and why, and mark whether they sit inside the range usable as of 1 January 2027. Do not look only at whether a name is among the 25; list every ingredient added for an antimicrobial, preservative, denaturant or cross-linking function.

The third line is dates. Put the production date of the last lot built to the current specification, the target arrival date at the US warehouse, and the start date for retesting the new specification on the same line. The most useful single line to add to the brief today is: who reviews our preservative system, by when, and where is the conclusion written down.

Sources

For more context, see the product development guide and MOQ 1,000 guide.

Want to develop a product in this category?

Market signals and production feasibility are not the same. Share your project requirements and we will review the right conditions with you.

Discuss your project